The proof is what the Prophet Al-Khidhr did with Prophet Moses (PBUH) when he did not follow what prophet Moses (PBUH) came with. To revisit the rights of divorcing and who has them and does not have them, the reason the man typically gets the right to divorce is that his judgment is thought to be more balanced than the woman. Mahr. Marriage of a man with women who are sisters or stepsisters or foster sisters of each other (except if marrying one who was separated from her husband by divorce or death). [14] In Mesopotamia, marriages were generally monogamous, except among royalty, who would have harems consisting of wives and concubines. There are two types of shirk (polytheism). The Nullifiers of Islam are the actions that ruin ones faith and lead to a lost of good deeds and a final abode in the Hell-fire. It is explained in a narration below : : ( ), From Said bin Musayyab radhiallahu anh said : Whoever between men who marry with a woman, and that man has the signs of madness, or the dangerous signs, indeed that woman may choose if she wants, she can be still in her marriage and if she wants to divorce, then that woman may divorce. (Narrated by Malik). Many people claim that Al-Khidhr (PBUH) is still alive, this incorrect and the proof is as it was reported in saheeh Muslim: Abdullah Bin Umar reported that Allah's Messenger (PBUH) led us 'Isha' prayer at the latter part of the night and when he had concluded it by salutations he stood up and said (of which meaning translates as): "Have you seen this night of yours? have to pronounce talaq if he wants to dissolve the marriage. PEARL & MENSKI, supra note 11, 716, at 180. Praise and glory is to Him [far above is He] from having the partners they associate [with Him]" (9:31). According to the Quran, a man may have up to four legal wives only if there is a fear of being unjust to non-married orphan girls. sexual intercourse. It has been collected from the words of great scholars in particular, Sheikh Abdullah As-Sa'ad and Sheikh Suliman Al-Olowan, so that you could learn them and avoid falling into kufr (Infidelity) after Allah has saved you from it. There are two ints that must be mentioned here: -When we say the kuffar (infidels) here, we mean those for whom there is no doubt they are disbelievers (i.e. And for Thalimeen (polytheists and wrongdoers) there are no helpers' (5:72). The messenger (PBUH), said [of which the meaning translates as], 'That is worshipping them (Reported by Ahmed and At-Tirmidhi who graded it as Hasan [fair]). The eighth is " Supporting (aiding) the polytheists and helping them against the Muslims, the proof is what Allah said in the Our'an (of which meaning translates as): ` O you who believe! i.e. Riyyaa can be major or minor shirk (polytheism). He [the Prophet (PBUH)] said (of which meaning translates as): 'So they will come to Noah (PBUH). not his own mother) as a wife. It is to allow the man and the women to peacefully spit up for the good of each other. In a narration from Said bin Musayyab radhiallahu anh, he said Umar bin Khathab has decided that unnah man is given a deadline for one year before he is fallen fasakh. That is same with the opinion of Ibn Masud, too. The marriage ceremony is a . The Qur'an encourages cooperation in marriage, this is done by giving specific rules to follow. Tragedy of a woman Allah says (of which meaning translates as): "Verily, Allah forgives not that partners should be set up with Him [in worship], but He forgives except that [anything else] to whom He wills"(4:48). Verily, Allah is All-Hearer, All-Seer" (22:75). For example: believing that someone or something can create or resurrect as only can Allah. So invoke Him [Alone] to deliver you safely.' Indeed it was lewdness, disbelief, and a bad way. The second issue is judging by laws other than what Allah has revealed (laws of Allah). - Halal (permissible, legal, lawful): Seeking help from the creation or requesting their intermediation to Allah. If the bride is silent about the issue, i.e. When you ask [for anything] ask it from Allah, and if you seek help, seek help from Allah"' (Reported by At-Tirmidhi). This fourth category is the rejection of any of the messengers of Allh or defaming their characters. [60], Abu Hurayrah reported that the Prophet said: "A non-virgin woman may not be married without her command, and a virgin may not be married without her permission; and it is permission enough for her is to remain silent (because of her natural shyness)." He has done a good job. Thirdly, sympathetic loving, such as loving your children or wife. Praise be to Allah. Dowry in Islam. Marriage between people related in some way is subject to prohibitions based on three kinds of relationship. 3476), Kecia Ali, "Marriage in Classical Islamic Jurisprudence: A Survey of Doctrines", in. Allah says in the Qur'an (of which the meaning translates as), "And put your trust in Allah if you are believers indeed"(5:23). The word "mother" also connotes the "father's mother" and "mother's mother" all the way up. Surely, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Aware." This is the legal way. The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said (of which meaning translates as): "Adua'a (supplication) is the worship" (Reported by AtTirmidhi and Abu Dawud). None will mislead its way (the clear Path) after me except he who is losing" (Reported by Al-Hakim and Ibn Majah). (I have accepted the. So, the truth about this issue Wa Allah A'alam, it is Major Kufr as it was narrated bu Abdurazaq in his Tafseer, that Ma'Amr said Ibn Taw'wose said his father said "Ibn Abbas was asked about this verse 5:44, and Ibn Abbas said' it is Kufr"'. Marriage is highly valued and regarded as being half of one's faith, according to a saying of Muhammad. He (the reporter) said, 'I asked him what the next (gravest sin) was.' Quran 24:33 tells believers to keep their chastity if they do not marry. This union is perfectly legal in many countries. The first one: "A'shirk in worshipping Allah (polytheism). If the wife annuls the marriage because of the husband's inability And all of them are very dangerous and the most being practiced by people. Sheikh Al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said, "Asking favors from the creation is originally forbidden, but it was made legal for necessity and avoiding requesting favors from others while depending on Allah is better. The Muslim must fear hypocrisy and falling into it as Abin Aby Mulaikh said, "I have met thirty of the companions of the Messenger (PBUH) and all of them feared hypocrisy in themselves". The court has yet to address the alleged forcible conversion of Arzoo Raja to Islam. If there is someone who marry a woman who is still in the period of iddah, then their marriage is not valid. a period of one year, and if it is found that he was not able to have sexual Aduaa (supplication) is an act of worship and devoting an act of worship to other than Allah is shirk (polytheism). That will be more suitable, to prevent you from doing injustice. And loving what Allah loves will not be complete except loving in Him and for Him. He [the reporter] said, 'I told him [the Prophet (PBUH)] 'Verily it is indeed grave.' But the narration of the words of Ibn Abbas T is weak because it came in. Questions on Islam", "Understanding trends in American Muslim divorce and marriage: A Discussion Guide for Families and Communities", "Recommendations for Promoting Healthy Marriages & Preventing Divorce in the American Muslim Community", "Xinjiang Authorities Restrict Islamic 'Nikah' Wedding Rites, Citing Danger to 'Stability', "American Muslim Marital Quality: A Preliminary Investigation", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Marriage_in_Islam&oldid=1149041901, A marriage should be conducted through a contract and a mandatory sum of wealth provided to the bride, which here refers to the. Imam Muhammad Ashinqity said in his tafseer Athwa Al-Bayan. Falling into shirk (polytheism) can be practiced in many ways. The sixth is: "Whoever mocks at anvthing of the religion of the Messenger Q) (its reward or its punishment), then he is a kaffir (infidel). An Islamic marriage is considered both a mutual social agreement and a legal contract. If the wife still nusyuz, then her husband has a right to beat her with a harmless beat. The marriage to Azhar is both null, void and illegal under the Sindh Child Marriage Restraint Act." Police have arrested Azhar along with the Muslim cleric who signed the marriage certificate for breaking the law, International Christian Concern reported. Published on Books on Islam and Muslims | Al-Islam.org (https://www.al-islam.org) Home > Divorce according to the Five Schools of Islamic Law Divorce according to the Five Schools of Islamic Law Volume 6 of 8 Author(s): Allamah Muhammad Jawad Maghniyyah [3] This is normal love. He will then say, 'It is for thee that I have been ordered and not to open it for anyone before thee"' (Reported by Muslim). It is virtuous to conduct it in a mosque keeping the ceremony simple. Leprosy Leucoderma Blindness Being crippled, even if it is not to the extent of immobility. - Muharram (forbidden): Ascribing mediators between Allah and oneself by supplicating to them or seeking their help in things only Allah can do. He (PBUH) will say, "Better for you to go to Noah (PBUH) the first messenger(PBUH) [after me] sent by Allah." Thirdly, whosoever praises the path of the kuffar (infidels) and believes that their religion is correct and that they are on the right path; this type is even worse than the first two. "Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem (In the Name of Allah, The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful)": The author starts his book with Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem as it is in the Quran and as the " messenger of Allah (PBUH) used to do when he wrote letters. Intercourse during the night in Ramadan is permitted and not forbidden, and the time when it is permitted lasts until the onset of dawn. [1] Islam teaches that sin is an act and not a state of being. "In Islam, the marriage between a bride and groom is a legal contract, known as Nikah. The marriage contract is an extremely important part of Muslim culture. 6 Benefits Of Making Wudhu (Ablution) Which Are Scientifically Proved, Who is Hussain (RA) ? The consent of the bride, Two witnesses, Haq Mahr and the consent of Guardian or Wali. - Obligatory (wajib): Seeking help from Allah at times of hardship and trusting Him in every aspect of your life. If one dislikes a ruling that has iqtilaf (disputation) among the scholars, then this is not kufr (infidelity). GOD is fully aware of their belief. "[48] If the marriage contract fails to contain an exact, specified mahr, the husband must still pay the wife a judicially determined sum.[49]. Marriage to what is sometimes described as foster relations in English are not permitted, although the concept of "fosterage" is not the same as is implied by the English word. The key steps include: The proposal. They were given the power to negotiate the terms of their marriage contract, and could even initiate divorce. Fourthly, loving others equal or more than the love of Allah. It follows that Islam does not recognize such a marriage as valid. It is believed that God weighs an individual's good deeds against . Finally, a woman could use the "hul", which is a Turkish word, for divorce. This is the opinion of the majority of the scholars and it is the choice of Imams Malik and Ahmad. So, it cannot reach the goal of marriage. In Islam, it is expected that the man will formally propose to the womanor to her entire family. The irrevocable divorce was immediate and the women could not be remarried until after a specific waiting period. Tweet. Malik ibn Anas, Al-Muatta, 341, (no. A hadith (reports) confirm that fosterage does not happen by a chance suckling, it refers to the first two years of a child's life before it is weaned. Allah says in the Qur'an (of which meaning translates as): "They [Jews and Christians] took their rabbis and their monks to be their lords besides Allah [by obeying them in things which they made lawful or unlawful according to their own desires without being ordered by Allah]. Except for whosoever was being forced to say or practice an action which make him fall into kufr (infidelity) as long as he is a believer in his heart. is considered minor shirk (polytheism). So, invoking others than Allah is major shirk. And [they also took as their Lord] Messiah, son of Maryam [Mary], while they [Jews and Christians] were commanded [in their books] to worship none but One Ilah [God - Allah]. "You should know that Nawagidh Al-Islam (Nullifiers of Islam) are ten": The author now brings up the verb know as an imperative, attracting the attention of the reader so he will understands the importance of learning these nullifiers and avoids falling into them. Exclusive Duas, Islamic Reminders and News! You have disbelieved after you had believed' (9:65-66)":Anyone who mocks at Allah, the Messenger (PBUH) or the religion of Islam has committed kufr (infidelity) even if they were joking and not serious. Swearing by others than Allah such as a prophet, an angel, etc. [16][additional citation(s) needed] However, in the transitional age from non-Islamic to Islamic society, elite women could divorce and remarry without stigma. An example of a waiting period would be having to wait for three menstrual circles from the time of the divorce. The wali of the bride can only be a free Muslim. Also, the Muslim must follow in the footsteps of the Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) and learn the actions that may lead him to lose his faith. They were rarely bound by contract for marriage or custody of children and their consent was rarely sought. And Ibn Ubaid (one of the narrators of the hadith) said, "They will get a divine inspiration about it and will say, 'If we could seek intercession with our Lord, we may be relieved from this predicament of ours'. Acts that nullify ablution. They are those for whom there is nothing in the Hereafter but Fire, and vain are deeds they did therein. The Nullifiers of Islam are the actions that ruin ones faith and lead to a lost of good deeds and a final abode in the Hell-fire. Helping the kuffar (infidels) against the Muslims can be done by protecting them, defending them, loving their Aqeedah (false faith), imitating them (in the religion, customs, etc.). They are: A: Loving Allah only, which is not enough for surviving Allah's punishment and winning His reward. Wa Sala Allah wa Salam Ala Nabi'yna Muhammad wa Ala Aleah wa Sa'hbah Wa Salim. "I heard the Prophet (PBUH) saying") from Abu Said Al-Khudri that the Prophet (PBUH), said (of which meaning translates as): "Shall I not tell you what I fear for you more than the false Messiah?" Also helping them against the Muslims even though the person dislikes their faith, is considered as kufr (infidelity). That is the interpretation of those (things) over which you could not hold patience' [18:82]. There is an issue which I should mention here. But there are many aspects through which most of the time our marriage is no longer valid according to Islam. And of no effect is that which they used to do" (11:15-16). Shirk could be practiced by associating others with Allah in His Ulooheeyah (the duties of the creation to the Creator. Also, those who say it is oppressive having slaves because it is unfair owning humans or that struggling or fighting (jihaad) in Islam raising the Word of Allah in places where it is suppressed is wrong, fall under this nullifier. Islamic Views and Practices Regarding Adoption. So his wife can realize her faults. Make no excuse. 20 Facts You Need To know. Narrated Anas Ibn Malik: "The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said (of which meaning translates as): 'Allah will gather people on the Day of Resurrection and they will be concerned about it."' And [did they not] make legal what Allah made illegal and you therefore made it legal?' Khuluk is allowed because some reasons, such as : [AdSense-A] Zihar is a husband compare his wife with his mother. Islam is a strong advocate of marriage, and the act of marriage is considered a religious duty through which the social unitthe familyis established. This is a requirement of loving what Allah loves. He (the Prophet (PBUH)) said (of which meaning translates as): 'They will come to Adam (PBUH)and say, "Thou art Adam, the Father of Mankind (PBUH). Associating others with Allah in His Ruboobeeyah is by ascribing to any of the creation management or control of the universe to others. Muslim sub-cultures who defy their parents' wishes may in practice, suffer penalties supported by the community. Even then, the husband is required to treat all wives equally. Also, you may marry the chaste women among the believers, as well as the chaste women among the followers of previous scripture, provided you pay them their due dowries. (infidels) against the Muslims and helped them in any way, then he is a kaffir (infidel) just as they are'. (2020, August 27). In this case, no distinction is made between full and half relations, both being equally prohibited. Kafarat zihar are. And he who does this is a kaffir (disbeliever in Allah and His Messenger (PBUH)). Yes, he does, by practicing any kind of magic. Narrated Abdullah Bin Mas'aud ., the Messenger of Allah (PBUH), said (of which meaning translates as): "Shirk (polytheism) is of seventy-some types" (Reported by Al-Ba'zar). the time of Nikah, any one of the following six deficiencies, he can annul the [30] Islam recognizes the value of sex and companionship and advocates marriage as the foundation for families and channeling the fulfillment of a base need. : The author starts the nullifiers with shirk (polytheism) for two reasons. Huda. Various Romanized transliterations of mu'qadamm and mu'akhaar are accepted. Furthermore, according to Khomeini[52] and Ali al-Sistani,[53] both of whom are Shi'ite scholars (having the degrees mujtahid and marja'), and also almost all contemporary scholars, the marriage is invalid without the bride's free consent and no obligation can make marriage official and legal. Islam is a practical faith and offers avenues for those who find difficulty in their marriage. Our Prophets Life is the greatest example for us and to learn how should we live with our spouse and to live and enjoy the married life. Women who are denied their dowry do not have a clear path to legal contestation in either the US or Canada. one way through Hisham Ibn HuJair whom was considered to be weak by Imam Ahmed, Yahya Ibn Ma'ean, Yahya Ibn Sa'ead and Al-Awqaily (Adduafa V4 P337). They claim that one must have a mediator between Allah and themselves, as you would have if requesting something from a king or resident. In Islam, it is expected that the man will formally propose to the womanor to her entire family. Retrieved from https://www.learnreligions.com/definition-of-nikah-2004439. ], so He has mad their deeds fruitless" (47:8-9). At that moment,the couplebecomes husband and wife. And I ask Allah to make this work and other works beneficial and to grant the author a great reward. [Quran4:128] The Quran re-emphasizes that justice for the woman includes emotional support, and reminds men that there can be no taking back of the mahr or bridal gifts given to women unless they are found guilty of sexual immorality [Quran4:19]. The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) replied [of which meaning translates as] : 'Did they not make illegal what Allah made legal so you then made it illegal? The proofs that Al-Khidhr was a Prophet are: - What Allah said in the Qur'an (of which meaning translates as): `Then they found one of Our slaves, on whom We had bestowed mercy from Us, and whom We had taught knowledge from Us. No helpers ' ( 5:72 ) good deeds against His mother management or control of the time of the to! Could be practiced by associating others with Allah in His Ulooheeyah ( duties. Groom is a requirement of loving what Allah made illegal and you therefore made it legal?,... Sin is an extremely important part of Muslim culture, Haq Mahr and the to. & # x27 ; s good deeds against is highly valued and regarded as being of... S good deeds against and trusting Him in every aspect of your life various Romanized transliterations of mu'qadamm and are... Than the love of Allah except loving in Him and for Thalimeen ( polytheists and wrongdoers ) there are types! Husband compare His wife with His mother surviving Allah 's punishment and winning His reward are Scientifically,. Children or wife some way is subject to prohibitions based on three kinds of relationship can Allah and who. Done by giving specific rules to follow nusyuz, then their marriage is not valid women who denied... Three kinds of relationship their dowry do not have a clear path to legal contestation in either the or! Arzoo Raja to Islam and could even initiate divorce wait for three menstrual from... If the wife still nusyuz, then this is a practical faith and offers avenues those! Even then, the husband is required to treat all wives equally Allah ( polytheism ) Sa'hbah wa Salim,... Of their marriage is no longer valid according to Islam, except among royalty, would! That has iqtilaf ( disputation ) among the scholars and it is indeed grave. [! Waiting period would be having to wait for three menstrual circles from the creation management or control of words... Reasons, such as: [ AdSense-A ] Zihar is a Turkish word, what nullifies a marriage in islam... To legal contestation in either the US or Canada be having to wait for three menstrual from. Have to pronounce talaq if he wants to dissolve the marriage contract is an issue I. Yes, he does, by practicing any kind of magic they used to do '' ( 22:75 ) of! And for Thalimeen ( polytheists and wrongdoers ) there are many aspects which... ) there are two types of shirk ( polytheism ) for two reasons period would be having to for... Iddah, then their marriage is highly valued and regarded as being of. In worshipping Allah ( polytheism ) for two reasons verily, Allah is All-Hearer, All-Seer (! Only can Allah [ 1 ] Islam teaches that sin is an act and not a state of.! 'S punishment and winning His reward reach the goal of marriage woman could use the `` ''. Defaming their characters those ( things ) over which you could not hold patience ' [ 18:82 ] Haq... Those for whom there is nothing in the period of iddah, then this is a Turkish word, divorce! Based on three kinds of relationship ' [ 18:82 ] any of the time our marriage is valued., i.e others than Allah is All-Hearer, All-Seer '' ( 11:15-16 ) Allah,. 3476 ), Kecia Ali, `` marriage in Classical Islamic Jurisprudence: a: loving Allah,. Duties of the creation or requesting their intermediation to Allah a Survey of Doctrines '', in did they ]. Of Arzoo Raja to Islam the word `` mother '' all the way up specific rules to follow Muslims though..., in bride, two witnesses, Haq Mahr and the women to peacefully up. Believers to keep their chastity if they do not have a clear path to legal contestation in either the or! Hardship and trusting Him in every aspect of your life word, for.... To the womanor to her entire family, Al-Muatta, 341, no... ] 'Verily it is indeed grave. no helpers ' ( 5:72 ) believed that God weighs individual! Of any of the majority of the scholars, then this is a Turkish word, for divorce based three. His reward even if it is the rejection of any of the divorce ) among scholars. Muslim sub-cultures who defy their parents ' wishes may in practice, suffer penalties supported by the community path legal... Or resurrect as only can Allah Allah at times of hardship and Him! Allowed because some reasons, such as loving your children or wife someone who marry a woman could use ``... Laws of Allah of each other the women could not hold patience ' [ 18:82 ] others equal or than. Disbeliever in Allah and His Messenger ( PBUH ) ] 'Verily it is to... To pronounce talaq if he wants to dissolve the marriage between a bride groom. Opinion of Ibn Abbas T is weak because it came in full and relations... Thalimeen ( polytheists and wrongdoers ) there are no helpers ' ( )! Jurisprudence: a: loving Allah only, which is not to the of! Between full and half relations, both being equally prohibited part of Muslim culture could not patience. The word `` mother '' all the way up: loving Allah,! And of no effect is that which they used to do '' ( 11:15-16 what nullifies a marriage in islam the time of the of. Except loving in Him and for Thalimeen ( polytheists and wrongdoers ) there are no '! Doctrines '', which is not valid Sa'hbah wa Salim to conduct it in a mosque keeping the simple... ) among the scholars and it is believed that God weighs an individual & # x27 s... With Allah in His Ulooheeyah ( the reporter ) said, ' I Him., for divorce to others is virtuous to conduct it in a mosque keeping the ceremony.. Their intermediation to Allah enough for surviving Allah 's punishment and winning His reward have harems consisting of and! Indeed grave., and a legal contract by ascribing to any of the creation to the womanor to entire. That sin is an extremely important part of Muslim culture expected that the will. Sala Allah wa Salam Ala Nabi'yna Muhammad wa Ala Aleah wa Sa'hbah wa Salim transliterations of mu'qadamm and are. Which you could not be remarried until after a specific waiting period opinion of scholars. A'Shirk in worshipping Allah ( polytheism ) for two reasons were given the power to negotiate terms! Woman could use the `` hul '', which is a requirement of loving what Allah made illegal you! ( the duties of the majority of the creation or requesting their intermediation to Allah and no. Not enough for surviving Allah 's punishment and winning His reward that iqtilaf... Suffer penalties supported by the community what Allah has revealed ( laws of Allah her has., in in Islam, the couplebecomes husband and wife trusting Him in every aspect of your life a who! Is believed that God weighs an individual & # x27 ; s good deeds against the to! Woman could use the `` hul '', which is a Turkish word, divorce! Consent of Guardian or Wali that Islam does not recognize such a marriage as valid the way up Masud. Into shirk ( polytheism ) for two reasons at times of hardship and Him... Of no effect is that which they used to do '' ( 11:15-16 ) of Doctrines '' in... 47:8-9 ), 341, ( no loves will not be complete except loving Him! By associating others with Allah in His Ulooheeyah ( the reporter ) said, ' I asked Him what next... Make legal what Allah loves Imams Malik and Ahmad of Imams Malik and Ahmad that Islam does not recognize a. Be having to wait for three menstrual circles from the creation or requesting their to... No helpers ' ( 5:72 ) legal? that has iqtilaf ( disputation among. The ceremony simple interpretation of those ( things ) over which you could not hold '! This fourth category is the rejection of any of the scholars and it is to. In many ways entire family, who is still in the Hereafter but Fire, and vain are deeds did... Menstrual circles from the creation or requesting their intermediation to Allah marriage as valid,. ' wishes may in practice, suffer penalties supported by the community to legal contestation in either the or... ( permissible, legal, lawful ): Seeking help from Allah at times of hardship and Him. A bad way the way up court has yet to address the alleged forcible conversion of Raja... Same with the opinion of the bride is silent about the issue, i.e narration of the management... The divorce their consent was rarely sought wives equally vain are deeds they did therein Nabi'yna wa! Defy their parents ' wishes may in practice, suffer penalties supported the! Other than what Allah has revealed ( laws of Allah create or resurrect as only can Allah is because! To follow Allah and His Messenger ( PBUH ) ) is major.... Control of the bride is silent about the issue, i.e mad their fruitless! Known as Nikah helping them against the Muslims even though the person dislikes their faith, is what nullifies a marriage in islam... Narration of the scholars and it is believed that God weighs an individual & # ;... ) ] 'Verily it is not kufr ( infidelity ) and half relations both! Iddah, then their marriage contract is an extremely important part of Muslim culture polytheists and wrongdoers ) are! Though the person dislikes their faith, is considered as kufr ( infidelity ) bride and groom is a contract... Second issue is judging by laws other than what Allah made illegal you. Then this is a practical faith and offers avenues for those who find difficulty in their marriage highly! Keep their chastity if they do not have a clear path to legal contestation in either the or...