When one talks about some of the greatest manga series of all time, it goes without saying that the name Fullmetal Alchemist would come up at some point or the other. I also think these groups of people make up a TINY portion of FMA's overall fanbase though :). To some extent it might be possible to see Hohenheim's different portrayal as part of the art difference, but I haven't seen either anime in a while, so it's hard to state in explicit terms what this is, and I really don't want to dig up some fan's "this is why the 2003 anime is better" illustration for this purpose. I think the people who hate FMA03 for not following the manga and being "filler ridden" (like 4 fucking episodes, get over it guys! My daily inspiration at the gym, Armstrong is a mountain of a man who serves the military with great honor and care. Gouyoku - Greed (2003)2. Plot. Hughes. It focuses more on the adventure and the plot, than the emotional roller coaster that is FMA. are all welcome. If you are logged in, please refresh. After reading this article youll have a little more understanding to determine which you want to watch first. It also makes me realize that Ed is literally fourteen years old when he begins his journey, because he acts so much more like a traumatized kid than in FMAB. EC1992. While one might argue that Brotherhood is a bit too fast-paced for one's liking especially during the early portions of the anime there's no denying that the pacing becomes more pleasing and satisfying as the series progresses. It focuses more on the adventure and the plot, than the emotional roller coaster that is FMA. rev2023.4.17.43393. Also, FullMetal Alchemist is a remake and not a sequel. Unlike the original anime series, the main character Alphonse in the Brotherhood is voiced by a girl. Although he was originally a slave, he was granted his near-immortality by Father well before the events of the series took place. The reason why I'm comparing these two anime because both of them involved military. Fullmetal Alchemist might be the first anime revolving around the series, but the episodes eventually caught up to the manga. I don't think either one is better, but they both have their faults but play well onto their strengths. Out of fear that YouTube wouldn't send it out to subscribers properly now, I reuploaded it. And anybody who's even remotely interested in anime should make it a priority to check out this show sooner rather than later. Meanwhile, Pride, Wrath, Sloth and Envy are entirely different. You can absolutely watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood without watching Fullmetal Alchemist. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. FMA:B, but Avatar is pretty decent comparison. FMAB uses advanced forms of visuals and has engaging backgrounds. If you enjoy this list, make sure to check out 30 of the best Fullmetal Alchemist AMVs of all time. This makes the action scenes look more mediocre than real. Top 10 Must-Watch Anime If You Loved Attack on Titan & Where To Watch Them! on Is Full Metal Alchemist and Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood the Same? Question Post. Besides, how can you dislike anyone who will save a stray cat? Father is also power-hungry who wants immortality over everything else, just like Dante but unlike Dante, he craves knowledge. Most of these different aspects I really don't understand. In FMA, Wrath is a failed transmutation of Ed and Al's mentor, Izumi, while Greed is created by Izumi's mentor. Though I do prefer Brotherhood since it has a happier ending. Your previous content has been restored. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is better than Fullmetal Alchemist based on its storyline, animation, and justice to the source material. The origin story behind the Homunculus in the 2003 series is far more interesting than Brotherhood's retelling. Clear editor. The first one was the original adaptation released in 2003; however, it diverged entirely from the manga. The new Fullmetal Alchemist series is completely worth it since it adapts the original manga from beginning to end. 1.2K. The central antagonist of the original FMA 2003 anime series is a furious woman named Dante, who controls seven homunculi that are named after the seven deadly sins. [spoiler]this is only funny if you have seen fma =p [/spoiler] Comment Reply Start Topic. What do you think is the main message of Full Metal Alchemist? And the latter isn't, sure it delves more into the "philosophical motifs" which it is trying to show but in terms of storytelling it falls flat. Among the most significant differences between the 2003 anime and Brotherhood are the depictions of certain Homunculus. Thank you, Ed, for letting us follow your adventures - we're happy to see you at the top of the list! Each series brought a unique perspective to the original manga story by Hiromu Arakawa. Her hair is dark brown with pink bangs. In Brotherhood, Wrath is Fuhrer Bradley, while Pride is his son; however, in the original anime, Bradley is Pride. What is the etymology of the term space-time? The Gate is also guarded by a being commonly referred to as Truth, and who is responsible for taking the required tolls from alchemists who perform human transmutation. 2 Flame Of Recca (1997) Banking on the popularity of the tournament setup shonen anime, Flame Of Recca is a memorable series known for its unique powers shared by its equally-intriguing cast. Versus Homunculus (Brotherhood)PART ONE1. To celebrate both Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood AND Fullmetal Alchemist: The Conqueror of Shamballa now being available on Crunchyroll, we ran a poll on the front page of Crunchyroll to figure out who the most popular characters from the franchise are in 2016. Who do you think took the top of the list? Ironically enough, his wanting to become a god was awfully greedy, even after he'd rid of that "flaw". At the same time, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood strictly sticks to the manga, with only 2% fillers. In a way, Brotherhood could be seen as a true FMA story but with less emotional impact. In the original anime, the Homunculus are the horrible aftermath of Human Transmutation. In FMA03, the Homunculi were the result of attempting to perform human transmutation and failing. Copyright 2022 Epic Media Labs. 2003 actually addressed the themes plaguing the protagonists (what composes humanity, etc) through interesting villains with backgrounds, I felt FMAB just boiled the theme down to teamwork is great and believe in yourself by the end, very generic. the Youswell chapter), and sometimes in a way that may affect characterisation (with the Ishval arc having been heavily cut down). Brotherhood, on the other hand, tries to wrap the whole thing up in one episode. The original FMA is somewhat more dramatic than the Brotherhood and definitely very different from the manga. She was the result of Ed and Al's attempt to bring back their mother. The manga and Brotherhood just have a lot better characterization and original characters in my opinion. Both of the brothers have embarked on their journey to find the Philosophers Stone, which can solve their problem. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. FMA lacks high-quality visuals and has less instinctive visuals. Ages since I watched either of them but I've honestly always been equally torn on them. I find it kinda stupid that 03 is better just because it's darker. In Brotherhood, Pride is King Bradley's son, Selim Bradley. The fans pick: Sacrifice: You must do anything to protect the one's you love. Also, I accidentally uploaded this as unlisted but in . Top 5 Anime Which Defined Everyone's Childhood, ** total_quantity ** | ** unit_price ** / ** unit_measure **. Another powerful moment lost in Brotherhoodis the passing ofbeloved characterMaes Hughes the Amestrian State Military officer who was extremely devoted to his wife and little girl. Nah FMA03 is shit, so glad it didn't get many votes. FMAB & FMAM's Pride (Selim Bradley) is not present in FMA03. Upload or insert images from URL. 2015 2:36:40 AM. I had more in mind, but in the midst of typing, I forgot what the rest was. Even though he lived for over 200 years, he was locked away for 130 of them, and pretty soon after he gets out and starts living everything is taken from him. 26%. What I'm wondering is: Does it present a lot of deep variations (plot-wise, character-wise or otherwise), or is it just the same series with updated art? Brotherhood also has more episodes (64, compared to 51) . 35%. There are still some aspects of the original manga series that simply make it better than the Brotherhood. FMAB has some god tier animation and is a lot more re-watchable than FMA. Psanime is not a cartoon! While I put FMA:B higher, is a bit overrated. FWIW, I loved the first series and I think the animation is way better in that one. HOWEVER, FMA is still better, just because I find emotional and smaller personal stories more intriguing than larger adventures(Not saying FMAB doesn't have those good character moments but FMA pulls it off so much better). In FMA03, the Gate is still the source of alchemy, but it also serves as a portal between the world of Fullmetal Alchemist and Earth. I was estatic when little me discovered the manga and later brotherhood. Spiral of Truth (Brotherhood)3. Sorrowful Stone (Brotherhood)PART EIGHT1. Both the 2003 version of Fullmetal Alchemist and the 2009 series, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, are worth watching. Fullmetal Alchemist is a Japanese manga written by Hiromu Arakawa and serialized in Monthly Shonen Gangan a monthly manga magazine published by Square Enix. In a way, Brotherhood could be seen as a true FMA story but with less emotional impact. Ante Meridiem (Brotherhood)2. At what point does the 2003 series and Manga/Brotherhood series start to diverge? The early episodes of Brotherhood were rushed out to make way for more content from the manga. With 64 episodes, the Brotherhood is longer than the original, which is a 50-episode series. ((Also 2003 Roy Mustang is the hands down best iteration of the husband.)). All Rights Reserved. Sloth looks like Ed and Al's mother, while in Brotherhood, Sloth is a big (much bigger than Armstrong xD) buff male with long black hair. I think the pacing is a bit fast early on, but thats what the original FMA is for. 1. I prefer that it forces its characters to compromise their ideals and morals rather than letting Ed and Al get all the way through the series with a happy ending and their righteousness intact. But besides his less-flattering traits, Mustang is a supremely competent leader and commander - an expert tactician who can bring the best out of everyone underneath his banner. However, since the manga wasnt finished yet, the anime diverged from it and built up its own story. Both the 2003 and 2009 versions of the anime delve into grey areas, yet, as Brotherhood goes along, the story becomes disappointingly more black and white. Hinamatsuri: An Anime That You Didnt Know You Needed, The Unwanted Bride Of Atticus Fawn by LaurG Review: A Slow Burn Romance, Immortal In The Magic World Review: Low Key Main Character Strikes Again, Top Anime Affiliate Programs To Boost Your Earnings (+ Manga), Webnovel Redeem Codes: How to Get Free Coins for Your Favorite Novels, 10 Best Web Novels to Read on Webnovel Part 2, 10 Top Cultivation Novels with Evil Main Character, 2 Web Novels with Huge Potential You shouldnt Miss, 21 Modern Day Harem Novels with an Overpowered Main character. And that's our list!! Alternative ways to code something like a table within a table? His glasses are smaller and not as round. Lurking (Brotherhood)3. Ignoring the alchemical principle banning human transmutation, the boys attempted . FMAB felt like a better-than-some shounen while FMA was like an existentialist drama. The Gate in Fullmetal Alchemist refers to the construct that allows for alchemy to exist in the world, and this is its only function in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. The whole thing regarding the creation of Homunculus is completely different in the first series. What makes Fullmetal Alchemist so engaging to watch is the constant mystery behind the Philosopher's Stone and the politics behind its creation. Like his name implies, Greed wants everything: fancy clothes, good food, your votesbut at 4th place, he was only able to claim 468 of your hearts. FMA VS FMA:B series finally continues with the homunculi analysis! Ed in this one is more smooth, but I tend to like Alphonse more in this series for some reason. While I put FMA:B higher, is a bit overrated. Also, FullMetal Alchemist is a remake and not a sequel. What's the difference between the FMA and FMA Brotherhood series? (Brotherhood)PART TEN1. The 2003 version buildsup the girl'srelationship with the Elric brothers overthree episodes. DreamUp. Epic Dope is the new home of streaming news, views and reviews. Fma because of the great inspirational messages. Questions, discussion, analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. Press J to jump to the feed. 2003 is fine, but I just didn't like how it handled certain characters. She plans to play God by extending her life forever with the help of Philosophers Stones. Brotherhood is a pretty darn faithful recreation. To improve the flow of this answer, the following abbreviations will be used: FMAM = Fullmetal Alchemist (Manga) All Is One - Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Trailer, Do small things with great love - Happy Sharing :). It's like everything that makes a show good doesn't matter, just how dark it is. Despite being based on the manga with the same basic storyline, the two anime series end up quite differently. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. But, in Conqueror of Shamballa, he gains his memories when he goes back to "our world" with Ed, after Ed brutally abandons him. In comparison, the Homunculus in the 2009 anime are just the human vices that Father separated from his body years ago. Generate your own AI work. Amongthe list of must-see anime is Fullmetal Alchemist, acaptivating series about two brothers named Edward and Alphonse Elric, who travel the world as State Alchemists to find the legendary Philosopher's Stone. As mentioned in the list of sympathetic anime villains you cant help but feel sorry for, the tragic 2003 anime version of Lust is a far more compelling character to watch than her Brotherhood counterpart. RELATED:Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood: All Of The Homunculi, Ranked. Whoa nelly what a time to be alive. While they both start the same way, the first one starts to develop following a whole different path than the Manga. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your . Meanwhile, in Brotherhood, the main antagonist of the series is a character who simply goes by the moniker "Father". I recently watched Attack on Titan and this anime is already in top 5 favorite anime because the story is very complex, the animation are very smooth, and a lot of characters are likable! Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. The main antagonists in both series are very different. In the fictional world of Amestris, brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric search for the Philosopher's Stone to restore their mangled bodies after a failed attempt to bring their mother back to life using the advanced science of alchemy. Juurin (2003)PART SEVEN1. They started off too slow with a lot of fillers, then picked up the pace towards the middle and kept it going. But I can tell you quite objectively, that even if the first one is not so faithful, it was of very good quality, speaking of plot twists, unexpected changes in history and other similar devices. We are building a home for otakus, nerds, and anyone sitting at home with superpowers likely to rule the world or maybejust obsessed with watching anime 24X7. Set . 03, and for me it isn't even close. However, while the original might not exactly be the optimal Fullmetal Alchemist viewing experience, there's no denying the fact that the first few episodes of the anime do a better job of fleshing out the early portions of the story, rather than Brotherhood. Bonus points for having Ling and Olivier, plus if I'm ever in the mood for a classic shounen-y climax this hits the spot in the best way. Ask the community. Is FMA: B a sequel? The fans pick: Transmutation circle. Anime & Manga Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for anime and manga fans. For more information, gohere. While this is obvious given the gap between Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood, one absolutely must commend the animation quality and fidelity of the latter for making every scene feel like a treat to watch. As Ling also uses a sword as a weapon, he and Wrath battle it out, while also using smoke bombs and grenades to try and defeat one another. Are they similar? Is the timeline messed up in episode 27 of FMA: Brotherhood? The only difference between the two is that Fullmetal Alchemist does not follow the manga in its latter half. Difference between Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood Story - Both FMA and FMAB are really good anime series adapted from the manga of the same name written by Hiromu Arakawa. Hosting Priority List and Window of Availability 1K page celebration post. Envy is a true sadist who relishes in human torment and mistreatment. FMAB & FMAM's Wrath (King Bradley) is called Pride in FMA03. FMAB has some god tier animation and is a lot more re-watchable than FMA. The Gate is the largest major change in the series. Another difference is the identify of the Homunculi themselves, with some Homunculi from FMAB & FMAM not appearing in FMA03 at all and others having their name changed. Whoa.Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lowartFollow me on Twitter: https://t. Is the FMA: Brotherhood movie considered canon? The winner of our poll - with a whopping 1,500 votes - is the Fullmetal Alchemist himself! xD ), while, in Brotherhood, she doesn't. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I prefer its artistic direction, atmosphere, character development, concept for the Homunculi, and ending. FMAB was darker in terms of colors but storyline was much more tense and gloomy in FMA. Hes on a journey to discover life one bottle of sake at a time! Jerik, At the same time, just because FMA diverges from the manga does not make it a bad anime. According to this anime, Earth and the world where Fullmetal Alchemist is set in are two different landscapes, and The Gate serves as a bridge between these two worlds something that the Elric brothers inadvertently cross at the end of the anime. He's not without his faults, but Al is the real deal - a genuine guy who always puts others before himself. You cannot paste images directly. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. In FMAB & FMAM, Hohenheim was a human Philosopher's Stone with a seemingly infinite supply of power. If you havent watched Fullmetal Alchemist you might be a little confused on why there are two series and which to watch first. His role in the anime is very minor, and he becomes trapped on the other side of the Gate after a confrontation with Dante that ended in failure. Unlike the original anime series, the main character Alphonse in the Brotherhood is voiced by a girl. YES the Mutang vs Ed fight was in the manga, and shit like Lust's side episode is key to her character in FMA03) are fucking dumb, and so are the people who hate FMA:B because they want to be edgy and in the seemingly smaller fanbase, and feel FMA:B is too generic and new or whatever. I can't give an informed opinion because I haven't watched one of them. In Brotherhood, Rose's skin is very white. I think both are very interesting and have good and bad things about them. With a Philosophers Stone at his core and a insatiable grin on his face, Greed is the most irresistible of Fathers children - after all, he just wants to live a happy (immortal) life. That doesnt necessarily mean they don't appreciate the arguably better character development and story telling throughout the first half of FMA03, and darker tones and imagery of that series. He was the result of Izumi Curtis's attempt to revive her son. In FMAB & FMAM the main antagonist was a character referred to as Father, a being of incredible power who is capable of performing transmutation at will, and without regard for equivalent exchange. FMA 2003 VS Brotherhood time. However, their origins in both anime are wildly different. Not at as good as FMAB, Both were really good, but I prefer FMAB - both for the story and because it's much more faithful to the manga (I really hate when adaptations radically differ from the source material). But the point about original ideas is solid. Fullmetal Alchemist is a hit manga thats written by Hiromu Arakawa. This allowed FMAB's storyline to be more faithful to FMAM's storyline because FMAB had a mostly-complete storyline to draw from FMAM. (Brotherhood not as much because of its botched early pacing and I just don't like its art style.) 132. Al is 10 (the age he was when this chaos happened) again and has no memories of the last four years. I've watched both. Ling And Lan Fan Vs Wrath And Gluttony. Brotherhood just got more off the rails and ridiculous for my tastes, and as you noted 2003 did a better job with focusing on the characters, which is my most important metric for most shows. When this happens, either filler for the anime is created or changes to the anime's storyline and characters are made so that the anime can continue to be developed. I love the pacing too and the fight scenes. The Symbolism Runs Deep in FMA Brotherhood, Why FMA 2003 Is Better Than FMA Brotherhood, The Differences Between the Two FMA Anime, Memorable Quotes from Fullmetal Alchemist, 15 Reasons Why FMA 2003 Is Better Than FMA Brotherhood. One thing, when you will listen to Yui's . Each Homunculus is also powered by a Philosopher's Stone. With 394 votes, the mustached Alex Louis Armstrong comes instrong. I love Brotherhood best. I refer to IT as it due to the fact that Envy itself has no identifying gender. Below are 15 reasons why Fullmetal Alchemist 2003 is better than Brotherhood. Instead, either the Philosopher's Stone powering them needs to be destroyed or its power drained (normally through forcing them to regenerate multiple times). You are majestic.Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lowartTime Stamps for each section:00:00:00 - Introduction00:02:10 - Part One: Mangahood and 2003's Gluttony, Mangahood's Sloth, Mangahood's Lust00:07:45 - Part Two: 2003's Lust00:13:00 - Part Three: Mangahood's Wrath00:18:19 - Part Four: 2003's Pride00:22:25 - Part Five: Mangahood's Envy00:25:13 - Part Six: 2003's Envy00:26:50 - Part Seven: Mangahood's Greed00:31:09 - Part Eight: 2003's Greed00:34:02 - Part Nine: Mangahood's Pride00:35:30 - Part Ten: 2003's Wrath and SlothBackground music (by section and order used):Introduction1. Shou Tucker is perhaps the best example of this, with his character being built up over the course of a few episodes in the original anime before the disturbing reveal. Which best symbolizes FMA? It follows the original events of the Manga. After all, the fact of the matter is that the story of the Elric brothers as they try and reverse the horrible effects of a resurrection gone wrong is one of the most engrossing tales ever told. His hair and beard are light blonde, and his ponytail is higher), In the first series, Rose's skin is brown. However, in the original anime, The Gate serves as something greater. The last major differences between the two series are their plots. Battle Scherzo (Brotherhood)2. i feel like the story of brohood was told better and had a more thought out conclusion (then again the big issue of 03 was essentially a love story and i am just, not a fan of those) and a more interesting plot. Everything from the antagonist, Dante, to its passive ending, was utterly different from the source material. In the first series, she has a baby (an ugly one, at that. Who the Homunculi are ( meh. The main antagonist in FMA03 is Dante. Both FMA and FMAB are really good anime series adapted from the manga of the same name written by Hiromu Arakawa. tournaments and even duel link ones.Oh, recently we have been doing several contests like our drawing contest, anime edit on TikTok and even a rather successful anime meme contest on our Facebook group.Join us to live your passion. Extremely unpopular opinion, but I couldn't get into FMA. Vote up the reasons FMA surpasses Brotherhood. In Brotherhood, Pride is King Bradley's son, Selim Bradley. As an Official Tournament Store licenced by Konami, we organised several Yu-Gi-Oh! 56%. The basic difference between FMAB and FMA is that the former is a faithful adaptation of the manga. As a result, Brotherhood isnt as suspenseful as the 2003 anime, which constantly questionsthe action of its characters andalludesto the inhuman creation of the Philosopher's Stone. The Gate in Fullmetal Alchemist refers to the construct that allows for alchemy to exist in the world, and this is its only function in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. on MyAnimeList, and join in the discussion on the largest online anime and manga database in the world! It is believed to be closer to the manga and follows the original events of the manga apparently. One thing I hate about FMA:B is the slow process to the ending plot which I find compared to others. To Be King (Brotherhood)2. The original Fullmetal Alchemists story was much more dramatic and incomplete compared to the second adaptation. I watched both because I didn't know of this distinction. Sloth, for example, is a vastly different character in Brotherhood than the original anime. Every single character in the original 50-episode Fullmetal Alchemist anime series is interesting, considering each one has a backstory that is carefully presented. Meanwhile, in Brotherhood, his character arc is wrapped up in just one episode. In Brotherhood, Hohenheim has a rectangle-shaped head. Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! The studio had three options either go on hiatus, start off with some filler arcs or create a completely original second half of the story. FMA: B was the second adaptation released six years later that followed the manga perfectly. We were so close to miniskirts for everyone! It isn't trying to be. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. FMA03's Wrath is unique to the series. @Mints97: I wasn't talking about Selim, I was talking about the character pride. 35%. I could never stand 03 because of how wrong it is if you've read the manga at that point. Also, it has the "brothers" theme and just an overall killer tone-setting OST. If nothing else I'm happy it made money because without FMA03 we might never have gotten Brotherhood adapted into an anime. So, for anyone who might be confused about what to watch and doesn't know what the difference between these two shows really is, here's an in-depth look into the wealth of differences between Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. On the other hand, FMAB was created when FMAM was nearing the end of its development. RELATED:Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood: 10 Awesome Quotes That Will Always Stick With Us. The Brotherhood is both visually appealing and spectacularly anime, which makes the action scenes look more real-like. Unlike Father, she is just a normal human being who created a Philosopher's Stone and has managed to live a long time by transferring her consciousness into the body of other human beings whenever she was nearing death. However, even before they can get past the threshold, they are confused between the two choices placed in front of them Fullmetal Alchemist or Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. It only takes a minute to sign up. 2023 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. i'm here for good boys having adventures, making friends & saving the world lmao. I like about everything in those two fights, animation, tension, soundtrack, voice acting (for both dub and sub), but if I had to pick, I think it would be Ed vs Greed